Star Trek: Discovery’s first season has come to an end, and therefore it is at last time for us to make our minds up about whether it is a worthy continuation of the Star Trek tradition. In order to do this, of course, we will have to delve into plot twists and examine all that happened, so be warned, here be spoilers.
Star Trek: Discovery, as you undoubtedly know unless you have been living under a rock, is the first Star Trek series to grace our screens since Star Trek: Enterprise. It is set roughly a decade before the events of the original Star Trek series and follows the adventures of the crew of the spaceship, USS Discovery. Sonequa Martin-Green stars as Michael Burnham, a science specialist on the USS Discovery. Unlike the central roles of previous Star Trek series, she is not the starship captain. Through her eyes, we get to see more of what happens aboard the ship, and we see it from a different perspective.
I last wrote about Star Trek: Discovery when only two or three episodes had been broadcast, which I felt was too early to say for sure what this show was going to be, and boy was I right about that. I was impressed with Michelle Yeoh as the captain of the Shenzhouh. I mentioned that Yeoh chose to retain her Chinese Malaysian accent for the role, just one of the ways the series diversifies its cast. I liked how this choice gave her complexity and also gave her a certain authority, to my ear, like a diplomat from the UN. I was perplexed that such a developed and interesting character would be killed off, never to be seen again, but now we know that she comes back, in a different form.
I also liked the Klingons from the very beginning. They wear sculpted waistcoats like Elizabethan pirates and actually look alien for the first time, rather than like extras in fake tan, or with bumps glued to their heads. They also have a hint of the styling of the Cenobites from a famous horror movie. This hint of horror is extended to other elements of their design, such as sarcophaguses (sarcophagi?) being attached to the exterior of their flagship. As the show went on, the Klingons became intimately involved in events, providing enemies for humanity, but also holding up a mirror to them.
I also noticed the design of the Discovery, and to a 3D nerd and spaceship designer like me it was then one of the most interesting things about the show. I liked the very unusual delta shape, based on a sketch by Ralph McQuarrie. The show soon gave me more to focus on than the spaceship, of course. I also liked that the Discovery is described as a science vessel, but the scientists have been press-ganged into the military against their will. This was something I’d never seen before in Star Trek, especially not on the ship that will be the center of the action. It was obvious even then that this was something different, the real question was whether it was still Star Trek, or was it something new entirely.
Now, with the benefit of hindsight, I can see more differences, but I can also see similarities. Discovery is different, compared to shows that have gone before, in that the show features a single serialized story throughout the first season. But this reflects a general change happening in television. The show is an evolution of Star Trek, but it is also a prequel to the original series, so Discovery is building towards the usual Star Trek ideals of racial unity, peace, the prime directive, and non-violent conflict resolution. These principles aren’t explicit yet, but they are there implicitly, guiding the action. For example, Bryan Fuller, one of the driving forces behind putting the show together, met with several actors and said that he wanted the show to be progressive. He looked at all of the roles through a colorblind and gender-blind prism. The series features minority, female, and LGBTQ characters.
Props such as tricorders, hand scanners, and communicators are heavily inspired by their designs in the original Star Trek series. The design of the USS Discovery is based on an unused Ralph McQuarrie design for the USS Enterprise from the unproduced film Star Trek: Planet of the Titans. It has harder lines than a typical Star Fleet ship, but it is no new design, it has history. Even the opening title sequence is intended to be a homage to past Star Trek series as well as an introduction to the more grounded and gritty tone of Discovery.
The show has been considered too dark and gritty a reboot by some, but I think this is wrong. I think we are seeing the same organization, the same Starfleet, but through more modern eyes. We are seeing the same universe too, but we are seeing more of its complexity. To our modern sensibilities, the idea that all Klingons are simply bad and violent, while all humans are good and compassionate, rings a little false. It is like film serials of the 50s about brave Western explorers prospecting for uranium in Arica. These guys were presented as unambiguous heroes at the time, but our more modern eyes would not be so kind to them. Now we know things were a little more nuanced than that, to say the least. The same is true of the brave heroes of Star Trek, and the bug-eyed monsters and mad gods they faced with courage and restraint. Entertainment has to evolve, and stories like this are now a thing of the past, but that doesn’t mean that what has replaced them is not Star Trek.
Star Trek: Discovery is something from now. We see the brave explorers, but we see their brave deeds with an eye less inclined to look away from their misdeeds. Discovery is about a complex world, and it comments on its characters’ actions. It spends a lot of time in the Mirror Universe, forcing its compromised and complex characters to face the truly villainous versions of themselves that are to be found there. It shows that, unlike in the Mirror Universe, these people are not the bad guys. However, humanity is capable of taking a dark path. Starfleet flirts with taking that path, but ultimately retreats from it.
Not so in the Mirror Universe. In the Mirror Universe, humans are a terrorizing force, exterminating alien life forms from the galaxy. They are comic-book bad guys, like Torquemada and his Terminators from the pages of 2000 AD. It’s easy to adhere to Starfleet’s principles when things are going well, but it’s when things aren’t easy that those principles most matter, and when the temptation is strongest to put our core values aside.
In today’s modern world, a world of waterboarding and rendition, it is now impossible for us to pretend American values are immutable and incapable of being set aside. A show that extends these insights to shape the way it presents the political organizations of the future is a Star Trek for now. Most tellingly, the show ends with the appearance of the USS Enterprise, commanded not by Captain Kirk but by his predecessor, Captain Pike. Discovery obviously feels that it has earned its place as a continuation of the Star Trek legacy, and I am inclined to agree.
I’m looking forward to season two, but in the mean time here is a plug for a sci-novel I wrote. Buy it from the link below…
Galaxy Dog (Dark Galaxy) Start Reading the Dark Galaxy Trilogy
The first book in the Dark Galaxy Trilogy, always the best place to start, is Galaxy Dog. It’s a little more old-school and fun than a lot of the sci-fi that is around at the moment. It has spaceships, robots, battles, and brave warriors rebelling against an evil empire. Click the book cover and go to the storefront you prefer to buy it now, or follow this link.
This is a universal book link (UBL) and you will be greeted with a page displaying all the places the book is available online. Just select the storefront you prefer and, if you want, also make this your default bookseller. From then on, every time you click a UBL you will be taken directly to the book you are interested in, on the storefront you prefer. The UBL even allows you to go to the Amazon store that matches your region.